The Story of Tooth #8

30 comments
Four years ago our then 7th-grade daughter tripped and fell during indoor track practice, cracking her front tooth.

Accidents like this were not uncommon in our family. Our struggles with coordination and balance would only become clear in hindsight.

An attempt was made to save her tooth, but it soon became apparent that the tooth was dying. The dentist advised a root canal. We didn't think twice.

Kristen had been our "seizure child," developing complex partial seizure disorder soon after our move to Colorado. A root canal seemed like a minor issue in comparison.

One year after her root canal we vacated our home. Her seizures abated, and for the first time in seven years she was off all seizure medications. She was struggling with knee pain, however, and wore a knee brace most of the time. She was fatigued and struggled with mood. The mold exposure had taken its toll on Kristen, just as it had on the rest of us.

As I searched intensively for dietary options to recover our health, I came across an article titled "The Effect of Root Canals on Health" by Paul Pitchford in his book Healing with Whole Foods. According to Pitchford:

. . . root canals may cause dangerous weakening of the internal organs; people with seriously imbalanced health who have had root canals performed or recommended should consider how to treat this dental problem as a priority in their healing process.

The idea that Kristen's tooth #8 was holding back her recovery was a new thought. New and overwhelming. I made an appointment with a holistic dentist. "It looks fine to me," he reassured me. "I think you're fine to leave it." It was exactly what I wanted to hear, but I still felt unsettled.

We began an aggressive "attack" on Kristen's knees through acupuncture. We also launched an all-out offensive with a strong anti-fungal diet, eliminating all grains, fruits, nuts, and sugars.

Kristen began to turn the corner. Her knees improved, her fatigue improved slightly, and she began to show signs of new life.

But there was something missing. Something holding her back. She showed very few signs of detox. No rashes like the rest of us. I thought again about her root canal and made an appointment with a different holistic dentist. He advised against extraction, suggesting a crown because of her age and the obvious cosmetic issue with front tooth #8.

I couldn't get past the nagging feeling that something was wrong with the root canal. And if I've learned anything in these last four years, it's to listen to that feeling.

I continued to research and came across the website Huggins Applied Healing. (Dr. Huggins is one of the world's most controversial dentists because of his stand on mercury fillings.) I read an article that shed some light on the issue of root canals, stating:

Extremely toxic anaerobic bacteria have been found and identified in and around root canals.

I called the Huggins office and requested a referral for a dentist in Arizona. I found one in Phoenix. Upon checking this dentist's website, I found a meridian tooth chart which shows the relationship between specific teeth and the rest of the body. According to the chart, tooth #8 has a direct relationship with the knee. In addition, tooth #8 is linked to conceptual connections and a whole host of emotional issues which have plagued Kristen for the last several years.

I felt sure the tooth needed to go. But what about Kristen? I presented her with the options.

1. Keep the root canal and get a crown, which will successfully deal with the tooth discoloration.

2. Extract the tooth and have a removable fake tooth.

She thought for a moment. "I think I would feel better without the tooth." She said it with strong conviction. I knew she was on board.

Kristen's tooth was extracted on May 31. It should have been a traumatic experience. Perhaps because a missing tooth pales in comparison to losing a home, health, and a community of friends, Kristen took the surgery in stride. In fact, later in the day she looked at me, smiled with a big toothless grin, and said, "I feel better."

A cloud had lifted from Kristen. The change was dramatic. Even one of the dental assistants commented the next day, "Kristen, you look better!"

Three days after the extraction Kristen began to show signs of die-off—the evidence of detox we had been waiting to see. She grew feverish and broke out in numerous rashes.


The symptoms slowly passed and Kristen continued to show signs of new strength and health. With tooth #8 now sitting in a Ziploc bag, Kristen has a new lease on life and an empowering story to tell.

30 comments :

  1. Great blog as always, Andrea. You are doing such a great job at figuring this stuff out!

    I have a very strong belief that my mouth is a huge problem for me. I don't have any root canals, and I got all my amalgams out safely in 1996 (at the very beginning of my illness). But I had four wisdom teeth dug out and four other teeth removed when I was about 20, and I think that the scars/holes have turned into a niche for bugs (including Lyme).

    It definitely feels like a mess in there.

    Do you have any thoughts?

    I'm so glad that Kristen is doing better. That's a great story!

    Best,

    Lisa

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks mom!
    This is wonderfully written and I feel so honored to have my own story written about on your blog.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Kristen,
    You have been a shining example to all of us through this. You are an inspiration.

    Love and admiration,

    Mom

    ReplyDelete
  4. Lisa,
    I just read something that I think will interest you. I'm going to find it and post it here in the comment section. You are onto something according to Dr. Huggins and others.
    Andrea

    ReplyDelete
  5. Wonderful post about a wonderful girl by a wonderful mom! Both beautiful!!

    ReplyDelete
  6. What a beautiful smile:) So glad you have continued to problem solve on all the possible causes Andrea. And kudos to you Kristen on having the courage to take this step too. So thankful you are showing signs of healing. kt

    ReplyDelete
  7. Andrea,
    Thanks for sharing Kristen's story. So glad she is feeling better, and I am inspired to think about my root canal....the tooth actually hurts sometimes, even tho it is "dead". Could you share more about the removable fake tooth? Any problem getting one that is low toxicity? Is there concern about her teeth shifting now that the tooth is gone? What about gum recession or bone loss? Although I know that these issues would be very minor compared to the issues she has been dealing with!

    God bless,
    Beth in PA

    ReplyDelete
  8. Beth,
    She was experiencing sensitivity in the tooth before it was extracted. The fake tooth is called a "flipper" and fits like a little retainer. To be honest she hardly wears it...she's quite comfortable with the missing tooth now and likes the "freedom". She knows to keep the retainer clean (tea tree oil) to keep it from carrying added pathogens.
    I'm not sure about the movement of the remaining teeth...that's a good question!
    We were advised to add some grafting to the gum after the extraction for later construction of a more permanent option, but we felt strongly it would be unwise to place anything on the gum...the best thing would be to just let it heal. Thankfully the oral surgeon agreed.
    You're right, these are small issues comparatively.You can call the Huggins website and see what they say about the toxicity of the fake tooth and possible movement. I'd be eager to hear what they say!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Lisa,
    Here is the article you might find interesting:
    http://livingnetwork.co.za/dentalnetwork/cavitations/cavitation-extraction-protocol/

    In their book "Uninformed Consent" Dr. Hal Huggins and Thomas Levy suggest toxin neutralization at the very least which involves nutrition therapy, Vitamin C, mineral supplementation, etc.


    It might be worth a call to the Huggins website to see what they suggest for you.
    It sounds like you have a gut feeling about this. I sure would follow it.

    Andrea

    ReplyDelete
  10. Beth,
    One other interesting note. Dr. Weston Price of the Weston Price Foundation conducted studies with rats and his findings have never been disputed.

    "Price was concerned about the pathological bacteria found in nearly all root canal teeth of that time. He was able to transfer diseases harbored by humans from their extracted root canal teeth into rabbits by inserting a fragment of a root canal root under the skin in the belly area of a test rabbit. He found that root canal fragments from a person who had suffered a heart attack, when implanted into a rabbit, would cause a heart attack in the rabbit within a few weeks. Transference of heart disease could be accomplished 100 percent of the time. Some diseases transferred only 88 percent of the time, but the handwriting was on the wall.

    Dr. Price discovered that root canals had within them bacteria capable of producing many diseases. They had no place in the body. Which is more important? The life of the tooth or the life of the patient? This is still the primary argument facing us today."


    Excerpted from this website:
    http://thehealingjournal.com/node/1493

    ReplyDelete
  11. Andrea,
    Thanks for sharing this info about Dr. PRice's experiments. One interesting thing....my root canal is on the right side, and everything on my right side seems affected: hair and nails grow more slowly, skin is rougher, wounds heal more slowly,etc. I have often been puzzled about this, and seeing the info you shared on meridians seems to shed some light on this. Thanks again for sharing with us all about your journey.

    Beth in PA

    ReplyDelete
  12. Wow, Andrea; your post couldn't have come at a more opportune time for me! Last night, I was suffering from what I thought was a tooth ache; today, however, there is no sign of it. During the night while I was hurting, I was wondering whether I should have the tooth extracted or try to get a root canal. My last foray with a dentist in my area was not good: I had a hypersensitive airways reaction to the acrylic they used to make a mold of my mouth and had difficulty breathing. THANK YOU so much for this post!

    Kristen, at your age, I don't believe I ever would have been able to make such a difficult decision! You are truly a strong young woman and I am happy that this health decision has helped you feel better!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Saw this on yahoo today. It doesn't have anything to do with your tooth story but I thought you might get a kick out of it.

    http://whoknew.news.yahoo.com/?nc&vid=25648317

    ReplyDelete
  14. My husband has a crown that keeps getting infected. We thought it was all mold related but now not so sure. It's a back tooth and he is hesitant to have it pulled fearing all the other teeth will shift. Are crowns like root canals?

    ReplyDelete
  15. Andrea I am in tears. Do you remember me saying that after changing my diet I felt better? But I still struggle with my health. I have never had any of the die-off symptoms you always write about. But I have had a root canal not sure what number tooth but I think I will be giving my dentist a call tomorrow and checking out that chart. I always feel like something is up with my mouth and it sounds like it very well might be.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Tonya,
    It is worth pursuing for sure. When something dead has invaded living tissue, as in the case of a root canal, it "requires" something of the body and if it's already fighting something (like a mold exposure), sure makes sense the body would have a tough time healing.
    Eager to hear what you find out, Tonya.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Lyn,
    Crowns are not nearly as invasive as root canals but can still aggravate the body by harboring bacteria. Makes sense to pursue this. I might inquire at the Huggins office....especially about the tooth movement question!
    Andrea

    ReplyDelete
  18. Ditto on all the previous positive comments.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Wow! I'll ditto Tonya. This brought tears to my eyes - for reasons I am sure you understand. What is different about a root canal that is causing such big issues? You mentioned recently just beginning this dentist part of the journey. Have you gathered much more info. in the last month or two? Feel free to message me if that is easier. I literally get scared every time I go to the dentist - to have amalgams removed and replaced. The Women's Clinic out East told me that even the composite could bring problems, but I just haven't had the strength to research this. I have very slowly begun the process of removal, but only with a "regular" dentist. I too so admire your tenacity in researching things. You are a blessing to so many of us! You should start charging a fee! :O)

    And, Kristen, you a part of an amazing family!!!

    ReplyDelete
  20. Ruth,
    I completely understand everything you're saying. I am currently reading a book titled "Uninformed Consent" which details some of the implications of mercury, root canals, and cavitations. It truly is fascinating and it all makes such sense. A root canal means something dead has invaded living tissue. This becomes a place to harbor bacteria and according to Huggins:
    "These bacteria produce waste products known as toxins. The toxins can either be picked up by the drainage system at the apex of the tooth, or flow down the dentin tubules into the periodontal ligament. At the ligament they can slip into the fluids around the tooth and flow into the bloodstream.....Some toxins have an attraction for specific tissue, so may lodge there."

    The mercury issue is big as well. I understand your fears on that. I had mine removed this spring...long story...but I'm glad I did. Hope to write about it soon.

    Thanks for the encouragement Ruth.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Did you use a holistic dentist or just your regular one? I can ate least say that my dentist was open to seeing research on why composites may not even be ok for some people. I'm considering taking a copy of your Tooth #8 blog to him.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I ended up with a holistic dentist who understood the ramifications of mercury in the mouth. Before my mercury removal I went to a regular dentist for a cleaning and evaluation. (I always request no flouride.) The protocol for mercury removal is critical for those with compromised health (oxygen, protection in the mouth, etc). It's nice your dentist is open!

    ReplyDelete
  23. *CAUTION* For anyone who's thinking about getting a root canal removed, a metal crown removed or replaced with a non-metal crown, amalgam (mercury) filling removal, and/or tooth extraction:

    - Make sure you find a GOOD holistic dentist that follows the Huggins protocol (don't just go to any dentist and some claim to follow the protocol, but weren't officially trained; you can verify this by calling Dr Huggins' office). Otherwise, you could end up feeling worse, much worse than before.

    I'm a big fan of Dr Huggins (his protocol has been a life-saver for me, literally!) and after almost a year of researching my health issues and their connection to my teeth issues, I have found:

    1. It's VERY hard to find a good dentist. BTW, just because they claim they follow the Huggins protocol doesn't mean they do it properly; you have to research it ahead of time, ask the right questions when you meet with the dentist, and be aware of what they're doing b/c sometimes they miss important steps.

    I can't tell you how many times I've had to "request" something from my dentist that's an important part of the Huggins protocol b/c they either forgot or only do it ONLY if you request it... It's quite frustrating, because they're important steps that my dentist who's outrageously expensive (3x more than the average dentist) and is the top holistic dentist in my area.

    2. In addition to "Uninformed Consent", everyone should *also* read "Huggins Client Information Packet" (it's actually a very large spiral-bound book that they sell at hugginsappliedhealing.com). Aside from some minor editing issues, the HCIP is the most helpful and informative hands-down! Trust me! I've been through 2 extractions, 1 root canal extraction, and several metal crowns replacements (with all-porcelain crowns) with *MCS* and there aren't enough to describe the major blessing that Dr Huggins has been in my life!

    C

    ReplyDelete
  24. Thank you so much for this article. My husband has a root canal that the doctors have suggested he have removed--and that he have a $3,500 implant put in its place. We have been putting that off, as we can't afford it, but in recent months he has also developed a terrible issue with his elbow. He has been to therapy twice (also out-of-pocket) and no relief in sight.

    I read your post, and looked at the meridian chart. Sure enough, his "bad" tooth is tied to the elbow. We called and he is having the extraction done tomorrow. I'll let you know how it goes with the elbow!

    I have two root canals on wisdom teeth, and that meridian is tied to heart issues. I will look into extractions for myself. I still have two amalgams to have removed--the last of the four quadrants, done one at a time--so I don't know that those extractions will happen this year. Any thoughts from Huggins about what to do if you can't have extractions done right away? Our naturopathic dentist is not covered at all by our insurance. All of this gets very complicated, doesn't it?

    Blessings,

    ReplyDelete
  25. Yes, it gets complicated, Amanda. I just read something regarding "what to do in the meantime"...I'll retrieve it later today...

    ReplyDelete
  26. In his book "Healing with Whole Foods", Paul Pitchford suggests both oxygen supplements and essential oils as alternatives to root canal removal. Specifically he says to ingest an oxygen supplement or an essential oil such as oregano or lavender oil three times a week.
    "Because the body tends to adjust to the effects of these detoxifying substances, it may be ideal to cycle between them on a weekly basis, for example, one week take oregano oil, the next week stabilized oxygen, and the final week lavender oil. Then repeat." Pitchford says you should notice an improvement after 7 weeks. If not increase the frequency of taking the remedies to 4, 5, or 6 times a week.
    One oxygen supplement he recommends is one found here:
    http://aerobiclife.com/

    (He suggests one drop of oil in 1/2 tsp. olive oil or diluted in water.)

    One other interesting suggestion from Pitchford is this:
    "The herb "horsetail" which has a strong affinity for teeth, strengthening, and purifying their entire structure. The supplement form of this herb must be specially prepared to be non-toxic." He says the raw herb can safely be decocted.

    These ideas aren't from Huggins obviously but I thought you'd be interested.

    I'd love to hear how the extractions go for your husband, Amanda.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Andrea,
    If you're still reading the comments on this thread, I'm wondering...what kind of rashes did Kristen show? Anything that resembled a cluster of bug bites? Or a boil? Or do they just look like patches of eczema? My dd has begun a different yeast protocol and I'm seeing things that are unfamiliar--with so many kids, I figured you've seen it all! :) If you have time, I'd love to hear a description of what various rashes look like. Thanks!

    Amanda

    ReplyDelete
  28. Amanda,
    These are exactly the types of rashes we have seen. There are so many different ones! Boils, bug bites, dry patches, patches of redness, swelling, claw marks, lips swollen shut, bumps, red marks...I could go on and on...We still see them 3 years later! If you email me I can send you some pictures if that would help.
    andrea@chrisfabry.com

    ReplyDelete
  29. Good timing for me. I am 39 and still have two baby teeth that the dentist wants to pull and give me a flipper. I thought I'd get implants one day when I could afford it but it sounds like the flipper is the way to go. I have also never had a cavity until the last time I went to the dentist and I turned up with 6.OUCH!! He has filled 3 and plans to fill the others and thinks a root canal is a possibility. I won't allow that now. I guess if nothing else I should just have it removed?? Should I allow him to fill the others? Thanks for your posts.
    Jeana

    ReplyDelete
  30. The Huggins office always leans in favor of removal. For questions like yours I find there office to be very helpful.
    Here is one mom's story of how her son's cavity healed naturally!

    http://www.thehealthyhomeeconomist.com/2011/05/how-i-healed-my-childs-cavity/

    ReplyDelete